top of page

How do you handle picky eaters?

10 minutes ago
6 min read

Man and boy in a kitchen making sushi rolls, with rice, salmon, cucumber and avocado; boy wears a Real Madrid Emirates jersey.

Anyone else making a full turkey dinner for Thanksgiving knowing full well that at least one of your kids favorite thing will be the roll? How we each handle the eating preferences of our kiddos varies from house to house and from kid to kid. No two are the same and we’ve each reached a place where it works for us.  We pick our battles, our menus, and as Rebecca reflects this is a blip on the radar - “I also remembered that my sister was a very picky eater and now, as a grown-ass woman, has the most diverse palate in the family. My son will outgrow his pickiness sooner or later.”


Jen, Bespoke Travel Planner from @GlobalOnDemandTravel

Bowl of fresh green beans on a wooden table beside black knife and fork, with a woven placemat and plates in the background.

I know what my kids love, and I really lean into those foods. Pasta, chicken, ramen, fruit, and green beans are always winners in our house. So we eat a lot of green beans! If there's a vegetable they'll happily eat, I'm more than happy to serve it over and over again. I don't feel the need to constantly reinvent the wheel or insist they eat a huge variety of foods at every meal.


I try to make meals that I know they'll enjoy while still encouraging them to try new things. Sometimes they're adventurous, and sometimes they just want what they know. I don't want mealtimes to become a battle or food to be a source of stress for any of us.


I also try to look at the bigger picture rather than focusing on any one meal. If they don't eat a perfectly balanced dinner one night, that's okay. There are other meals and other days to make up for it.


At the end of the day, I'm not trying to win any awards for creative parenting or perfectly balanced meals. I'm just trying to raise healthy, happy kids who have a good relationship with food. Some days that means trying something new, and other days it means chicken, pasta, and yet another big bowl of green beans. And I'm perfectly okay with that!


Rebecca, Woman's Leadership Coach from @PleasantlyAggressive

Elegant dining room with a set table for six, cream linens, red flowers, crystal glasses, and sunlight through tall windows.

My oldest eats just about everything. He dislikes some fruits, and enchiladas (strange, I know), and isn’t a big fan of soup, but otherwise, I never have to work around him.


My other child has a lot of allergies which were identified when he was only 1 year old. He also has a diagnosed overactive gag reflex, which meant that some foods would trigger his gag reflex and they became unsafe foods - they scared him. That means his diet was restricted from a very early age. It meant I had to make separate meals, and was frequently worried about what was safe. He outgrew some of his allergies, while some still remain. But at some point I stopped trying to introduce a lot of new foods and he showed strong aversions. I refused to be forceful but constantly worried about him getting enough nutrients and having a well-balanced diet. He was growing, wasn’t malnourished, and seemed to be thriving, so I have just accepted that he is perfectly fine.


I also remembered that my sister was a very picky eater and now, as a grown-ass woman, has the most diverse palate in the family. My son will outgrow his pickiness sooner or later. As a teenager, he is making the decision to try more vegetables and dishes that he previously avoided. He’ll get there, and it will be on his terms.


Ashley, Millennial Mom Nutrition Coach from @AshleyBreaksTheCycle

Yep, I’m a nutrition coach who makes separate meals for her kids. Go ahead and judge me! 😂


Hands fold navy napkins over a table set with bowls of penne, plates, and a JUST WATER carton during a casual meal

One of the best pieces of advice I received from my kids’ pediatrician was that it can take eight or more exposures to a food before a child starts accepting it, asking for it, or simply stops complaining about it being on their plate. That always stuck with me.


My kids eat a variety of fruits and vegetables throughout the day, so I’m not overly concerned that they’re missing out on nutrients just because they won’t eat the salmon and asparagus I’m making for dinner.


It’s more of a pain in the ass for me because I’m making two meals most nights. And sometimes, quite frankly, they’re fending for themselves with whatever they can throw in the air fryer or a bowl of cereal.


My 13-year-old daughter is by far my pickiest eater, and I’ve reached the point where I no longer cater to her pickiness. I spent YEARS making things specifically for her, only for her to take two bites and leave the rest for me to throw out. She’s perfectly capable of making herself pasta or mac and cheese at this point, and it’s just not worth the nightly battle for me anymore.


Given my profession and my own history with food, I’m very intentional about how I talk about food around my kids. I don’t want them associating certain foods with guilt or feeling like they need to earn their dessert by finishing their vegetables.


I encourage them to eat a variety of foods, explain why certain foods are beneficial to their bodies, and continue to offer things even when I’m fairly certain they’ll turn their noses up at them.


Could I do a better job of expanding their palates? Absolutely. But between school, sports, homework, running a business, and everything else that comes with motherhood, I’m choosing my battles.


And can we just stop judging other parents for how they feed their kids? Unless you’re standing in someone’s kitchen every night at 6 p.m., you really have no idea what their situation looks like.


My goal is to raise kids who understand how to nourish their bodies, enjoy food, and eventually make balanced meals for themselves without having a complicated relationship with eating.


For now, what we’re doing is working for our family. And I’m perfectly okay with that.


Ali, Book Aficionado from @The BookClubCart

Man and young girl make salsa in a kitchen, slicing red onion and stirring ingredients; fridge covered with photos behind them.

I hate to even say this, but I feel so blessed that we haven’t had extremely picky eaters in our house. I honestly credit a lot of that to my husband being in the food industry and making food fun for the kids from day one. He has always included them in the experience, whether that’s trying new things, talking about food, or just making meals something we enjoy together.


We’ve had one rule from the beginning: you have to try everything, and if you didn’t like something before, we’ll give it another try at least once a year. Food is such a big part of our household, and while my kiddos may not love every meal we make, they are generally willing to eat just about anything.


That doesn’t mean they haven’t gone through phases of favoring certain foods over others! We’ve definitely had our share of favorites, but we try to find a balance between honoring what they enjoy and continuing to introduce variety and encourage them to try new things.


Kim, Interior Designer from @Reverie.and.Root & Founder of Spilling Goodness

Smiling man and girl stand at a stove in a stylish kitchen with blue hood, white tile, and floral art, cooking together.

Coming off of life with an infant with reflux and into a toddlerhood, there was a phase when we really struggled to get our oldest to eat enough. Our pediatrician recommended a few books and while I don't remember the specifics at this point, the main takeaway was that as the parent, I was "in charge" of what was offered and when and as the child, she was "in charge" of IF and how much to eat. If that meal was refused, it was to be offered at the following meal. The recommendation was to react calmly and explain, "If you'd prefer to eat your meatballs for breakfast, that's fine, I'll save them for you."


Now, I realize how this sounds and we didn't exactly follow the letter of this law (much at all). But, we did standardize one dinner for our family. Dinner is dinner. If you don't like the vegetable, try it. (We've had some of the best laughs around the dinner table over the quanity of parmesean cheese added to zucchini.) And, if you truly hate it, get something else that's green. Our youngest will gladly trade in most veggies for a handful of spinach - no dressing, just a handful - ha! For breakfast and lunch, I just remind kids to include a protein and "something from the earth" - fruit or vegetable along with what they choose. Aside from reminders from time to time, they make pretty good choices.

 
 
bottom of page